The primary advantage of bookless arenas, according to Houghton? You can repurpose the saved space for work, study or collaboration areas.
Otherwise, she lists three reasons why they’re not such a great idea quite yet.
“First, some people simply prefer physical media — they don’t want to read on a device,” Houghton says.
Second, she points to the issue of the digital divide. Those who aren’t necessarily technologically literate may need extra over-the-shoulder help with the devices in a way that would require a large operation and, consequently, a big budget.
“A huge element is training staff, and that’s even presuming that the library can afford enough of these devices to meet the demand,” Houghton explains.
And the biggest issue? Most content is simply not available digitally to license and purchase.
“So your selection of best-sellers and popular media just went down the toilet because 99 percent of that is not available to libraries digitally,” she says.
Many publishers don’t license to libraries, and those willing to do business often have what Houghton considers outlandish terms — too expensive or unrealistic for a library’s allowance.
Libraries — with books — are still important, no matter how many digital devices we own.
“If someone suggested the idea of public libraries now, they’d be considered insane. If you said you were going to take a little bit of money from every taxpayer, buy a whole load of books and music and games, stick them on a shelf and tell everyone, ‘These are yours to borrow and all you’ve got to do is bring them back,’ they’d be laughed out of government.”—
Peter Collins, The Secret Life of Libraries (via jingc)
True. Publishers used to try to sue libraries, arguing that they were violating their copyright by letting people read books they hadn’t paid for.
A friend of ours doesn’t like libraries for this very reason. It’s a bizarre consequence of politics that we’ve moved so far away from the library that we’d never find our way down this road if we had to start over. The Internet used to be much more library-like in its conceit. (We remember hopping on our modems circa 1994 to use the Internet through a text-based interface. Yes, we’re that old. We know what GOPHER is.) Then AOL started charging $20 a month to take a hit of the pipe, and here we are today.
Soon, your Kindle will replace your library card: Amazon is rolling out some great new features to Kindle users, including book lending and access to 11,000 public libraries. No word on when they’ll be out, though. source